The Best Water Heater: Complete Reviews And Buying Guides 2022

Victor Sawyer
  May 20, 2024 11:28 AM

Determining the best water heater is tricky as you must consider various factors. Also, there are too many of them to check, taking a lot of time and effort. 
I have tried many models, each performing differently. Some of them outperform others. Hence, I will discuss those products in detail, show you their pros and cons, and suggest the best deal. 
Following my post, you can also learn how to choose the most suitable water heater for your needs. So let's read on to discover! 
 

Our Top Picks

Compare Products

1
  • GB SCORE

    GB SCORE is a ranking system developed by Guessbest.com. Guessbest.com has no relationship or impact from any manufacturers or sales agent websites. Learn more

    9.5
  • Brand
    Rheem
2
  • GB SCORE

    GB SCORE is a ranking system developed by Guessbest.com. Guessbest.com has no relationship or impact from any manufacturers or sales agent websites. Learn more

    9.4
  • Brand
    Stiebel Eltron
3
  • GB SCORE

    GB SCORE is a ranking system developed by Guessbest.com. Guessbest.com has no relationship or impact from any manufacturers or sales agent websites. Learn more

    9.3
  • Brand
    Rheem
4
  • GB SCORE

    GB SCORE is a ranking system developed by Guessbest.com. Guessbest.com has no relationship or impact from any manufacturers or sales agent websites. Learn more

    9.2
  • Brand
    Bosch Thermotechnology

Last update on 2024-05-20 / Affiliate links / Images, Product Titles, and Product Highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API

Types Of Product

Customers can choose between three types of hot water heaters. These appliances can be more modern hybrid types or traditional heaters. Each has benefits to consider.  

Storage

The most popular type of water heater is the one with a storage tank. They have an insulated tank heated by electricity or natural gas.

Within the system, gas units heat the water using heating elements and regulate the temperature with a thermostat. When the hot water runs out, you have to wait for an hour for the tank to refill and reheat. 

Tankless 

Tankless water heaters warm water just when needed. It indicates that they wait to start warming water until you ask.

Tankless heaters use electricity or gas to work. When you open the tap, cold water flows to the heater via a water pipe. The system will heat the water using an electric oil or a gas burner.

Tankless water heaters provide an infinite hot water supply, in contrast to tank water heaters. They do, though, have speed limits. Most people have a hot water production rate of five to six gallons per minute.

Hybrid 

The idea behind hybrid heat pump water heaters is that it is simpler to utilize. They use the heat extracted from the air to heat the water.

A hybrid heater compresses the surrounding air, releases cool air, and keeps the heated air to heat water. 

Because the hybrid heater employs electrical coils to work when there is a high demand for hot water, it gets the name. This machine performs best in warm regions since it collects the air's heat.

Buying Guides

After selecting which type of water heater to go for, you need to consider other factors. Each of them contributes to the overall performance of the machine. 

Gas vs. Electric

Cost is the main difference between gas and electric equipment. A 40-gallon gas heater typically costs from $1,300 to $2,600, not factoring in installation costs. 

Otherwise, spend between $950 and $1,500 for a similar-sized electric machine. 

Gas is less costly to use than electricity, although running costs vary with electricity and gas prices. Electric heaters typically cost $42 a month to operate, compared to roughly $30 for gas counterparts.  

Vents

You can install your electric water heater almost anywhere because it doesn't need vents. Meanwhile, when setting up a gas machine, you must consider the vent installation. 

Burning gas water heaters release moisture and gasses. To get rid of these wastes, the machines need a ventilation system. Thus, their locations in your house will be limited since the vents take up space. 

Size

Consider your demand and your family size to decide how big your water heater should be. The bigger the machine, the more water you can use. 

Often, a 40-gallon water heater is enough for a 4-person family. If your family has more members, add ten gallons for each. 

Although tank water heaters may supply water to multiple locations simultaneously, they take more time than tankless heaters to heat water, which may result in an unpleasant cold bath.

A standard Tankless Water Heater can heat up to five gallons of water per minute. But this rate may limit the amount of hot water that enters your house, particularly if several taps are utilizing hot water all at once.

Efficiency 

The unit's efficiency rating reveals how much of the power a water heater consumes to heat water. For example, a heater with an efficiency rating of .70 uses 70% of its energy to work. 

An electric water heater has a higher efficiency rating than a gas model. I'm so impressed with the rate of .98 of this Bosch Electric Mini-Tank Water Heater.

However, operating a gas heater will be far less expensive than using an electric machine since gas is much cheaper.

Due to the difference in electricity and gas rates, this efficiency rating doesn't accurately reflect how much you should expect to spend on the appliance. Instead, use it to compare heaters of the same type. 

Displays

The digital controls on modern water heaters enable owners to set the water heater to turn off at specific times. This feature is excellent, especially for families who are on vacation. 

Although a digital display could add to the appliance's initial cost, it enhances the water heater's efficiency, eventually leading to cost savings.

FAQs

1. How often should I flush a water heater? 

You should flush the heater at least every year. This method helps you avoid some potential issues that Sediment may cause in the future. 

You can learn how to drain and flush a water heater tank from this video:

2. Can a leaking water heater explode?

Yes, although it's a rare case. It happens with pressure relief valves on broken or clogged electric or gas heaters. The water heater may explode if too much pressure rises, technically shooting the appliance like a rocket.

3. How much do I pay to replace a hot water heater?

The cost of installing a water heater ranges from roughly $804 to $1,547, including the cost of the appliance itself, labor fees, contractors, and home repair specialists.

The price of tankless heaters is much higher than that of tank heaters. They are, therefore, towards the top of this category and may be pricey to replace.

4. What are the signs my heater is going out? 

Signs of a malfunctioning water heater include:

  • Banging noises within the tank

  • A drop in water temperature

  • Rust-colored hot water

  • Water accumulating at the base of the tank

5. Can I still shower if my water heater is leaking?

Yes. Even if the leak is terrible and you want to shut it off, you can still take a shower but expect no hot water.

Final Thoughts

 All the products I mentioned in this article are worthwhile. I really love this RHEEM Tankless Water Heater. Its tankless design is perfect for my limited space. It also does an excellent job of reducing energy consumption and promoting air quality.  

 I highly recommend this Stiebel Eltron Tankless Water Heater if you prefer electronic water heaters. It's a good space and energy saver. 

 It comes down to your personal preference to determine the all-rounder.

 Hopefully, you can select the best model from my list. Thank you for reading!